Thursday, December 27, 2007

Wednesday, December 26, 2007

The Benefits Myth

So, my Girlfriend’s sister seems to enjoy making everyone in the world feel bad for her and a favorite weapon is to complain about not having a job with benefits. Basically, she decided to pursue a master’s degree in an unpopular field at an out of state college and is now riddled with debt while unable to find employment in that unpopular field. She does have a job and it’s not bad, just not up to her own untenable standards.

Part of the constant complaining that her presence comprises is about how “lucky” I am to have a job with benefits that pays well. In her eyes, I’m some type of cartoonish fat cat bad guy because I’ve never worked as an adult for nine dollars an hour. Lucky decision I made when choosing an employable degree and in-state college. Lucky interview I had for my current position. Lucky to work 50 plus hours a week and never say no to supervisors.

Fortunately I can summon the attention span of a praying mantis when I feel like it and I learned years ago that arguing with someone like that was about as useful as learning to fry crickets. In basic summation I am sympathetic to her and others in the same situation even in the face of criticism for being deemed successful. I can’t help though to believe her anger to be misguided and ill-informed. Misguided because I think everyone should own their decisions, including career. And ill-informed because of what I refer to as “The Benefits Myth”.

I started to think about benefits recently as the company I work for recently changed health insurance providers. The new company sent a regionally ethnic speaking (heavy and insultingly Hispanic accented) stooge to introduce them. I knew that everything was devolving once the speaker referred to the company’s goal as promoting my “health care destiny”. As I understand the presentation the new company’s goal is to encourage customers to take charge of their own health care from diagnosis to treatment, basically the worst thing a customer could do is get sick in any way that requires a real live doctor and anything stronger than can be had over the counter. I wish I was kidding when I refer to the presenter’s promotion of webmd.com and the virtues of aspirin.

Of course this new plan had the requisite increase in costs over the old one even though its actual usefulness was difficult to appreciate. This fact led me to do some looking on the web in regard to health care plans available to the individual. On eHealthInsurance.com I was able to configure a local quote from Blue Cross/Blue Shield with the same level of coverage as the company my employer chose for less. Now it was only about two dollars less a month but nonetheless I was stunned. In addition to the insurance stooge, my employer sent an HR tool to preach about how much the company cared about and contributed to employee benefits.

Besides feeling that I had learned the true health insurance contribution of my employer I also believe the benefits myth discredits those who complain of a lack of benefits. In five minutes of research I located an identical plan at a nearly identical price that anyone in my area can obtain.

It would be naïve of me to believe that my new argument would cause my Girlfriend’s sister to flinch. I’m lucky because I can afford my benefits, remember. Because I know that my argument can’t go anywhere with those devoid of logic is the reason why I’m writing about it.

Just because my employer negotiated with a particular insurance company doesn’t mean they’re the only option. Complaints about health care in this country are as common as Starbucks today and a lot has to do with the myth of lack of accessibility. Of course, the majority of complainers believe that the government can do a better job thinking about and providing healthcare for them and are simply too indifferent to explore any options before speaking. It’s that choice that they are really complaining about and the desire for simplicity that drives the universal healthcare bandwagon.

The unfortunate thing is that those pushing for such an extreme don’t bother with facts as they jump to conclusions. The assumption of righteousness on the subject only blinds ignorance and leaves the rest of us to deal with the consequences. Because of such pomposity we may one day be “lucky” to be relieved of 60% of our incomes as taxes to pay for it.